If you're deep into MLB The Show 25, you already know the difference one elite card can make in Ranked Seasons, Events, or even Conquest. Every year, a handful of cards rise above the rest—not just because of their attributes, but because they perform way above expectations. This year is no different. Whether you're grinding or eyeing the buy MLB The Show 25 stubs option, these are the cards dominating the meta.
Here are the 10 most overpowered cards in MLB The Show 25 right now.
1. 99 OVR Ken Griffey Jr. (Signature Series)
The Kid is back and better than ever. With maxed-out power against both sides, elite fielding, and perfect swing mechanics, this card is an automatic inclusion in most top-tier lineups.
2. 99 OVR Randy Johnson (Milestone)
Left-handed batters don't stand a chance. Johnson’s slider is still one of the most devastating pitches in the game. His stamina and K/9 make him a complete workhorse, ideal for Ranked Seasons.
3. 98 OVR Mike Trout (Live Series)
Even without being a 99 overall, Trout continues to be a glitch. The combination of speed, power, and defensive range in center field makes him indispensable.
4. 99 OVR Chipper Jones (Awards)
Switch-hitters with a top-tier swing are always a premium, and Chipper is still elite in this role. He handles both lefties and righties, and with 90+ fielding at third base, he’s not just a bat.
5. 99 OVR Shohei Ohtani (Two-Way Player)
A dual threat with elite hitting stats and a solid five-pitch mix? No other card offers this much flexibility. Ohtani can carry an offense and still be your ace for a 9-inning showdown.
6. 99 OVR David Ortiz (Prime)
If you’re looking for raw hitting power, Big Papi is the guy. He absolutely destroys right-handed pitching, and his swing feels tailor-made for MLB The Show 25’s engine.
7. 98 OVR Ronald Acuña Jr. (All-Star)
What sets Acuña apart this year is his ridiculous arm strength paired with elite bat speed. He’s a nightmare on the basepaths and a lethal leadoff hitter.
8. 99 OVR Nolan Ryan (Milestone)
His fastball still touches 102, and his 12-6 curve keeps hitters off-balance. Add in Outlier, and you’ve got a legend who can dominate even the best opponents.
9. 97 OVR Julio Rodríguez (Future Stars)
J-Rod might not have the same historical weight as others on this list, but his card plays way above its rating. His swing is crisp, and he has 5-tool upside across the board.
10. 99 OVR Hank Aaron (Signature Series)
Few cards offer the consistency that Hank brings. He can hit for power to all fields, and with maxed clutch ratings, he always delivers in the late innings.
How to Get These Cards Without Breaking the Bank
While you can get lucky pulling some of these cards from packs, many players choose to buy MLB The Show 25 stubs to secure their favorites directly from the market. However, keep in mind that the MLB 25 stubs price fluctuates—especially when new cards drop or major programs update.
One tip: sites like U4N often get mentioned in community discussions for tracking prices and providing updates on stub value trends. Just make sure to check the game’s policies and always use reliable sources if you decide to go that route.
These overpowered cards aren’t just flashy—they dominate because of how they play. If you're building a competitive lineup or just want to enjoy the most fun MLB The Show 25 has to offer, these are the must-haves. Whether you're grinding missions or considering the market, keep an eye on the MLB 25 stubs price and make strategic decisions.